I read in a recent League of American Orchestras email that a study has just been
completed that asked people to describe their personality traits and then asked subjects to list their favorite styles of music. Apparently there is a link between heavy metal and classical music fans due to their shared “love of the grandiose” and big, loud, brash music. According to the researcher, besides their age differences, both are basically the same type of person. Hmmm. Maybe Wagner was a precursor to Metallica.
An earlier League email referenced a book, The Mating Mind, written by Evolutionary Psychologist Geoffrey Miller discussing why we find musicians and singers sexy. “Looking at things from a biological point of view,” writes MacLeod, “we would normally expect women to be attracted to men with qualities that indicate good genes that can be passed on to her children or those that show he can look after a family, like a wad of cash for instance. Music doesn’t seem to serve any practical purpose. Musical ability, along with other creative skills, are rather like a human version of the peacock’s tail; something that has no survival value, but has evolved precisely because it is found attractive by the opposite sex….
As a former professional musician, I can pretty safely say that if this is true, it unfortunately has fallen outside of my personal experience. I’m wondering if any of you would care to comment on these two interesting subjects?
Posted in


Guest (not verified) | Fri, 09/12/2008 - 11:27am
- reply
- Month
- Week
- Day
- Table
- List
»Guest (not verified) | Mon, 09/15/2008 - 4:26pm
Hi Guest,
Thanks for the comment and the lead. The book sounds interesting!
Jim
- reply
- Month
- Week
- Day
- Table
- List
»Guest (not verified) | Tue, 09/16/2008 - 11:01am
I can personally attest to the validity of "The Mating Mind." Sure, there is an aspect of magnetism and attraction surrounding musicians on stage. There is a mystique about them.
These same musicians may be socially awkward once offstage, but that alluring talent and attraction is definitely there when they are playing. We assume their personalities to mirror their skill.
As far as "music having no survival value" aside from it being it being found attractive by the opposite sex, I don't think that is true in the least.
Humans have always had and will continue to have the need to express, create and be understood. Surviaval based on the fact that people find musicians attractive alone - seems to me a pretty flimsly argument.
- reply
- Month
- Week
- Day
- Table
- List
»Guest (not verified) | Tue, 09/16/2008 - 5:30pm
Hi Guest,
Thanks for the intriquing comment. You say in your comment, "I can personally attest..." Care to share a story or two from your personal experience? I tend to agree with you. It's hard not to imbue the people performing on stage, in front of large, adoring crowds, with a sense of attractiveness. I also agree with you on your final point that music/arts MUST play a greater survival role in human beings. Can't wait to see the research on that one!
Jim Hirsch
- reply
- Month
- Week
- Day
- Table
- List
»